Wednesday, July 5, 2017

Subjective candor, objective truth

MANY times in the course of talking with people, I hear
the rationalizing expression that at least they were true to
themselves, to their feelings and understanding of things even if what
they did was actually not good.
  
            On these occasions, I needed to pause for a while before
slowly explaining to them that while acting on the basis of their
feelings and understanding of things certainly have some value, it is
not enough. In fact, it can be very wrong.
  
            To act on subjective candor alone does not automatically
translate into getting into the objective truth. And that’s simply
because truth and goodness and everything that flows from them can
only come from God, not from us.
  
            Of course, in explaining this delicate topic, I make sure
that the culpability of one’s mistakes depends on the degree of
responsibility one has with respect to knowing the objective truth
that can only come from God. There are those whose capacity to know
the truth in God is so compromised that they could not be guilty of
the wrong they did. This is the case of those with invincibly
erroneous conscience.
  
            All this distinction between subjective candor and
objective truth is somehow treated in the gospel of St. John
(14,15-21), where we read that Christ promised to send us the Spirit
of truth, the Paraclete or Advocate, who will always be with us as
long as we love God, that is to say, as long as we follow God’s
commandments, which is what loving actually entails.
  
            In that gospel, Christ reassured us that he would never
leave us orphans. He will always be with us and would even manifest
himself to us in the Spirit, as long as we love him by following his
commandments.
   
            This is a piece of Good News that we need to spread around
more widely, because many people are of the belief that especially in
matters of opinions, like in business and politics, they do not need
to refer themselves and things in general to God. For them, it would
just be enough if what they think, say and do correspond to their
common sense, or to some worldly values like practicality,
profitability, etc.

             That kind of outlook has actually caused great havoc in
our life as it would easily lend itself to injustice and inequality,
to a culture where the strong dominates the weak, the rich exploits
the poor. Injustice and all kinds of abominations can be defended and
promoted under the protection of law.
  
            That’s the case of legalized abortion, for example, where
the completely defenseless baby can now be eliminated, since the baby
in the mother’s womb would already be defined as not human yet, or
that it is just a bunch of tissues.

             We need to instill in everyone the truth about where truth
and all goodness can be found. We may not be able to know all the
truth because of our limitations and also because of the mysterious
character of a phenomenon, but as long as always refer ourselves to
God, at least we do not go beyond what his clear commandments have
already defined.


No comments: